NewbieNudes is a user submitted amateur porn site with real home made amateur content that has been running since 2002. The site says they are close to 4 Million members and receive over 1,500 daily submissions from their users. On my the first look I think this is actually true, as there are a lot of pictures I've never seen before. So IMHO real amateur stuff.
Whats definitely is a big plus is that they are removing content that they believe is of a "revenge" nature. We don't like to expose girls on websites, we also don't support this, so newbienudes.com gets a big thumbs up from us!
There really is no more genuine amateur site than NewbieNudes!
To use the site you have to register, which is completely free. Nevertheless you can also buy a premium account to enable more interaction and videos. NN also uses their own currency called "Nudles" - The concept is that you can earn and spend Nudles just like you would on any other loyalty program, but you can also give Nudles to other members. You can decide to do this once you are a recurring visitor and more familiar with the site.
You love real amateur porn and an active community? NN is the way to go